Flat Rate vs. Hourly Rate: Making the Right Choice for Your Business
- Jobber Blueprint /
- Articles /
- Flat Rate vs. Hourly Rate
Before you can price your services, you’ll have to choose whether you want to charge a flat rate or by the hour.
This guide will help you understand whether hourly or flat rate pricing will be more profitable for different types of services to help you pick the best pricing strategy for your business.
What is flat rate pricing?
Flat rate pricing means charging a set price for a job or service, no matter how long it takes to finish.
Instead of billing customers by the hour, you provide a fixed cost for the entire job. This fixed pricing method is often used in situations where the tasks are standard, predictable, and can be easily estimated.
For example, a lawn care business might charge a flat $175 to aerate a lawn that’s 10,000 square feet. The customer knows exactly what they’ll pay, regardless of whether the job takes one hour or several.
What is hourly rate pricing?
Hourly rate pricing means charging the customer based on the amount of time spent doing the job.
Instead of offering a flat, fixed price upfront, you bill the customer for each hour you spend on the task. This pricing model is common when the job is less predictable, or when the amount of work needed can vary.
For instance, a cleaning company might charge $45 per hour because the time needed can vary depending on the size and condition of the house or building. An hourly rate makes sure the business gets paid fairly for all the time spent on the job.
Flat rate vs. hourly rate: What are the pros and cons?
When deciding whether to use flat rate or hourly pricing for your home service business, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons of each. Knowing these will help you determine which pricing method is the best fit for your business.
Both methods have their benefits and drawbacks.
Flat rate pros:
- Predictable income: You’ll know exactly how much you’ll earn for each job, which makes it easier to plan and budget.
- Potential to earn more: If you can complete jobs quickly, you can take on more work and increase your profits.
- Simple bookkeeping: You don’t have to track every minute spent on the job, which makes invoicing easier and faster.
- Transparency: Customers appreciate knowing exactly what they’ll pay before you begin the work. This helps them budget better and be reassured there won’t be any surprises when they receive the bill.
- Easier budgeting: Customers can plan their expenses more accurately, making flat rate pricing a popular choice for predictable services like routine lawn care.
Flat rate cons:
If a job is quicker than expected, the customer might end up paying more than they would have with hourly pricing.
Risk of underestimating the job: If a job turns out to be more complicated than you expected, you could end up spending more time without earning more money.
Less flexibility: If a customer wants to add more tasks after you’ve already begun the job, flat rates can make it difficult to renegotiate.
Potential for disputes: A customer might feel the flat fee is too high, especially if the job seems to take less time than they expected.
Hourly rate pros:
- Flexibility: You get paid for all the time and effort you put into a job, especially if it turns out to be more complicated than expected.
- Easier to account for time: You’ll track and bill for the exact time spent on each job, helping you make sure you cover all costs.
- Trust with clients: When customers see you’re billing them for the actual time worked, they may feel more confident they’re getting a fair deal.
- Fair pricing for simple tasks: Customers only pay for the time actually worked, which can be an advantage if the job is straightforward and doesn’t take much time.
- Perception of paying for actual work done: Customers might prefer hourly pricing because they can see exactly how much they’re spending.
Hourly rate cons:
- Income varies: Since hourly work can take different amounts of time, your income might be less predictable.
- Meticulous time tracking: To avoid disputes and ensure accurate billing, you need to carefully track the time you spend on each job.
- Not knowing the final cost: Customers might worry about how long a job will take and what the final cost will be. They could be reluctant to agree to hiring you.
Perception of being taken advantage of: If the job takes longer than expected, customers might feel you’re intentionally being slow to earn more money.
Flat rate vs. hourly: Pros and cons
| For the business owner | For the customer | |
| Flat rate pros | Predictable income Potential to earn more Simple bookkeeping | Transparency Easier budgeting |
| Flat rate cons | Risk of underestimating the job Less flexibility Potential for disputes | Pay more for simple jobs |
| Hourly rate pros | Flexibility Easier to account for time Trust with clients | Fair pricing for simple tasks Perception of paying for actual work done |
| Hourly rate cons | Income varies Meticulous time tracking | Not knowing the final cost Perception of being taken advantage of |
Flat rate pricing examples
To help you understand how flat rate pricing works, here are a couple examples for different home service industries. These illustrate how to calculate the fixed rate based on costs and desired profit margins.
Construction
Assume a construction company offers a basic bathroom renovation up to 40 sq. ft.
Their estimated cost of materials is $3,500. This includes tiles, fixtures, paint, and plumbing materials.
Their estimated labor cost and travel is $3,100. 60 hours of labor at $50/hour, plus $100 for travel expenses.
The base totals $6,600. Factoring in their 20% profit margin, the flat rate for the service is:
Flat rate = $6,600 + ($6,600 x 0.2) = $7,920
Lawn Care
Assume a lawn care business offers a mowing service for medium-size yards up to a half-acre.
Their estimated cost of materials is $10 for fuel and mower maintenance.
Their estimated cost of labor and travel is $50. One hour of labor at $40/hour, plus $10 for travel expenses.
The base totals $60. Factoring in their 20% profit margin, the flat rate for the service is:
Flat rate = $60 + ($60 x 0.2) = $72
READ MORE: How Much to Charge for Lawn Mowing
Hourly rate pricing examples
To illustrate how hourly rate pricing works in practice, here are a couple more examples for different services. These show how businesses use an hourly fee to manage varying job complexities.
Electrical
Electricians often use hourly rate pricing for repair or installation work in homes. For instance, if they’re called to troubleshoot electrical issues—such as flickering lights—the time needed can vary depending on how complex the problem is.
Hourly billing ensures the electrician is compensated for the time required to properly diagnose and fix the issue.
Adding 50% for overhead costs and profit margin, the hourly rate is this:
Hourly rate = (Employees’ hourly wage x Number of employees) x 1.5
Once you’ve calculated your hourly rate, multiply that by the number of hours worked to get your total amount for the job.
Cleaning
A cleaning company might charge an hourly rate for deep cleaning services. Unlike a regular cleaning—which likely has a set time and cost—deep cleaning can take longer.
By charging hourly, the cleaning service can cover the time needed to thoroughly clean areas like baseboards, ceiling fans, and behind appliances.
READ MORE: How Much to Charge for House Cleaning
Charging per hour protects you from surprises, such as a client booking you for four hours, if you go to the home and then you find out that the shower is going to take you four hours to clean. It’s a lesson learned.
When to choose flat rate vs. hourly rate
The main factor in choosing between flat rate and hourly rate is how you plan to calculate the cost of your services.
A flat rate is ideal when the scope of work is predictable. Examples include:
- Plumbing: Common repairs like installing a fixture.
- Lawn care: Routine services like edging that need similar time and effort.
- Cleaning: Regular cleaning tasks that have a consistent time requirement.
An hourly rate is ideal when the time needed to do the work can vary significantly. Examples:
- Landscaping: Custom installations that may need more time than initially planned.
- General contracting: Complex jobs that require a flexible approach.
- Construction: Projects with many variables (like materials) and potential delays (like weather).
Paying employees: Hourly vs. flat rate
Deciding whether to pay your employees an hourly wage or salary—versus offering subcontractors a flat rate for specific jobs—is crucial for managing your business.
Employees who work regularly and consistently are usually paid hourly or on a salary basis. On the other hand, subcontractors hired for specific tasks or projects often earn a flat rate.
Understanding the benefits and drawbacks of each method will help you make the best choice for your business.
Hourly rate pay
Paying your employees an hourly wage means they earn a set amount for each hour they work. This method is straightforward and ensures your team is paid for all the time they spend on a job.
Pros:
- Fair compensation: Your employees are paid for the actual time they work. This is a fair arrangement for tasks that are unpredictable or require extra attention to detail.
- More focus on quality: Without the pressure to finish a job quickly, your team can take the time they need to do high-quality work.
Cons:
- Less incentive to work quickly: Hourly employees may be less motivated to finish jobs quickly. This can lead to inefficiencies.
- Potential for higher labor costs: If a job takes longer than expected, you’ll pay more for labor. This may affect your profit margins.
Flat rate pay
Paying your employees a fixed amount for completing a job can be motivating for those who work efficiently. Flat rate employees may complete jobs faster, saving your business time to take on more jobs.
Pros:
- Encourages efficient work: A flat rate technician has the incentive to complete jobs quickly without compromising quality. This can lead to better overall productivity.
- Predictable labor costs: As a business owner, you know exactly how much you’ll be paying for each job. It helps with budgeting.
Cons:
- Pay doesn’t account for complexity: For complicated, unpredictable tasks, flat rate pay might not accurately reflect the time and effort that’s needed. This can lead to potential frustration for employees.
- Concerns about quality: If workers rush to complete jobs quickly, the quality of work may suffer. This can lead to unhappy customers or needing to re-do the work.
Paying employees hourly vs. flat rate: Pros and cons
| Pros | Cons | |
| Hourly rate pay | Fair compensation More focus on quality | Less incentive to work quickly Potential for higher labor costs |
| Flat rate pay | Encourages efficient work Predictable labor costs | Pay doesn’t account for complexity Concerns about quality |
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Consider the complexity of the job, how long it might take, and the expectations of your customers. Flat rate pricing works well for straightforward tasks with predictable timeframes, while hourly pricing is better for jobs that can vary in time needed. Think about your business’s goals, like whether you want to encourage speed or ensure detailed, precise work.
-
Use flat rate pricing for simple, repeatable tasks where you can estimate the time and cost accurately. Use hourly rate pricing for more complex or unpredictable jobs where the time needed may vary.
-
The choice between flat rate and hourly pay rate depends on the type of work your team does. For routine tasks that can be done quickly, flat rate pay might encourage efficiency. For jobs that are more complex, hourly pay ensures your techs are compensated fairly for their time.
-
Flat rate pricing provides predictable income, simplifies billing, and motivates your team to finish jobs quickly. It also informs customers of the cost upfront, which helps with transparency.
-
Flat rate pricing is common in industries like electrical work, HVAC, plumbing, and some aspects of construction. It’s also used in cleaning services and landscaping for tasks like cleaning houses and mowing lawns, respectively, where it’s easy to estimate the time and effort.
Join over 200k service professionals that trust Jobber
Get Started